Why Machining Small Complex Parts Is Draining Your Budget: When to Switch to MIM

A 9 g 17-4PH lever with a cross hole, an internal slot and two M2 threads takes three setups on a 5-axis mill, turns about 80% of the bar into chips, and still needs a deburring pass under a magnifier. At 200 pieces that is a reasonable way to make it. At 20,000 pieces a year it is one of the most expensive ways to make a small steel part.

Metal injection molding (MIM) exists for that second case. It is not a better machining process. It is a different cost structure: a large one-time tooling cost, then a low and stable piece price for parts that are small, complex and made in volume. The question for an engineering or sourcing team is not “is MIM good?” but “at what point does this part stop belonging on a mill?”

Where the money goes on a small machined part

On large, simple parts, CNC cost is mostly machine time. On small, complex parts it is mostly everything around the cut.

Cost driverWhat happens on CNCWhat happens in MIM
Material removalBuy-to-fly ratios of 3:1 to 10:1 are common; you pay for steel that leaves as chipsNear-net shape; runner and sprue are reground within limits
Setups and fixturesEvery face or angle that cannot be reached adds a setup, a fixture and a datum transferAll features formed in one shot; the tool carries the geometry
Small featuresSlots under 1 mm, M2 threads and deep small holes need small tools, low feeds and frequent tool changesMolded in, within limits on core pin length and wall thickness
Hard alloys17-4PH in H900, 440C or 4140 at 40+ HRC slow cutting and wear toolsHeat treatment happens after shaping; hardness does not affect forming
Deburring and inspectionEdge breaks and burr removal by hand on internal intersections; 100% inspection on critical featuresNo machining burrs; inspection by sampling once the process is capable

None of these show up as a separate line on a machining quote. They are folded into a piece price that stays roughly flat no matter how many parts you order. That flat line is the problem: volume does not make a machined part much cheaper.

Signals that a part should move to MIM

A part is a strong MIM candidate when most of the following are true. Two or three is a reason to ask for a DFM review. Five or more usually means you are overpaying today.

  • Part mass between about 0.5 g and 100 g, ideally under 50 g
  • Largest dimension under roughly 100 mm
  • Annual volume above 5,000 to 10,000 pieces, or a lifetime volume above 20,000
  • Three or more machining setups, or features at compound angles
  • Internal features: cross holes, undercuts, slots, knurls, logos or threads that slow the cut
  • Material is a steel, stainless, titanium, copper, Fe-Ni or tungsten alloy (not aluminum)
  • Most tolerances are ±0.3% of nominal or looser, with only a few critical dimensions tighter
  • The part is an assembly of two or more machined pieces that could become one

When MIM is the wrong answer

There are parts we tell customers to keep on the mill. Switching them would raise cost or risk.

Too many tight tolerances. As-sintered MIM holds about ±0.3% to ±0.5% of nominal, because every part shrinks 15% to 20% linearly during sintering. One or two features tighter than that can be finished by reaming, coining or a single machining step. When ten features need ±0.01 mm, the part becomes a machined part that also carries MIM tooling.

Thick or heavy parts. Sections above about 8 to 10 mm debind slowly and risk cracking and porosity, and feedstock cost scales with mass. Past roughly 100 to 150 g, investment casting with finish machining is often cheaper.

Low or uncertain volume. Below a few thousand pieces over the life of the part, the tooling rarely pays back. If the program might be cancelled after one build, keep it on CNC.

Aluminum. Aluminum MIM is not a practical production route; the oxide layer on aluminum powder prevents normal sintering. Aluminum parts go to die casting, machining or extrusion.

A design that will keep changing. A production MIM tool is expensive to modify after it is cut. If the geometry is still moving, freeze it first, or use a prototype tool (more on that below) and accept that some changes will need new steel.

Switching is a redesign, not a copy

A drawing made for machining usually carries features that only make sense on a mill: thick solid sections, sharp internal corners, flats added for clamping, and tolerances applied uniformly because the machine could hold them. Copying that drawing into a mold gives a heavier, riskier MIM part than necessary.

The changes we most often make when converting a machined part:

  1. Core out thick sections and keep walls between 1 and 6 mm, with adjacent sections within about 1.5:1. This cuts feedstock cost and reduces distortion during sintering.
  2. Add radii of at least 0.3 mm to internal corners. Sharp corners that cost nothing on a mill crack during debinding.
  3. Remove clamping features and any flat that only existed for fixturing.
  4. Mark the critical-to-function dimensions and relax the rest to ±0.5% or ISO 2768-m. Keep one secondary operation for the one bore or face that really needs ±0.01 mm. A molded part plus one reaming step is often still well below the machined price.
  5. Add a flat setting face so the part sits on a standard ceramic setter during sintering without custom supports.

Material equivalents

Most machined steel grades have a MIM equivalent with properties defined in MPIF Standard 35 (MIM edition) or ASTM B883. The properties are close to wrought, but not identical, and you should check them against your load case.

Machined fromMIM gradeTypical relative densityNotes
303 / 304 / 316 barMIM 316L96%–98%Non-magnetic when sintered correctly; good corrosion resistance after passivation
17-4PH barMIM 17-4PH96%–98%Heat-treatable to H900–H1150; ductility below wrought at the same hardness
4140 / 4340MIM 4140, 4605 (Fe-2Ni-0.5Mo-0.5C)96%–98%Quench and temper after sintering; plate or coat for corrosion
440CMIM 440C96%–98%High hardness and wear; lower toughness than wrought
Ti-6Al-4VMIM Ti-6Al-4V95%–98%Oxygen control is critical; ASTM F2885 for surgical implants; higher cost than steel MIM
Copper / CuCrMIM copper95%–97%For thermal and electrical parts; conductivity a little below wrought

If the part is load-critical, test MIM samples to your own fatigue or impact protocol. Static tensile data from MPIF 35 is not a substitute for a fatigue test in a hinge or latch that cycles thousands of times.

How the switch actually runs

The risk in switching is not the process; it is doing it in one step with no fallback. This sequence keeps the machined supply running until the MIM part is proven.

  1. Free DFM review (7 working days). We mark the features that drive cost or yield risk and propose changes, with the reasoning for each.
  2. Prototype tool and samples (tool in 4 to 5 weeks, samples 10 to 15 working days after). A single-cavity prototype tool in pre-hardened steel gives sintered parts in the real alloy. It also gives shrink data per dimension, which goes into the production tool.
  3. Validation. Dimensional report per cavity, density per ASTM B962, tensile or hardness to the agreed standard, and your own functional and life tests.
  4. Production tool. Multi-cavity if volume justifies it, built with the shrink data from step 2 and steel-safe on critical features.
  5. First article and PPAP at whatever level your industry requires, then ramp. Keep the machined source qualified until the first two or three production lots ship clean.

The prototype step is what makes the switch affordable to test. It turns “will MIM work for this part?” from a tooling bet into a short experiment.

Before you send the drawing

If a part on your BOM matches most of the signals above, send us the STEP file, the material, your annual volume, and the three dimensions that matter most to function. Within 7 working days you get a free DFM review and a tiered quote: prototype tool (4 to 5 weeks) and sintered samples (10 to 15 working days after the tool is ready), a pilot lot, and production pricing at your volume, with the current machining price as the line to beat. If the answer is that the part should stay on the mill, we will tell you that too.

Share a link to your STEP file and drawing through our quote request form, or email leo@lichengmim.com.

Related reading

Scroll to Top